Never knowingly underduped

21 April 2015

A variety of supermarket products

UK supermarkets are, according to Which? magazine, "duping shoppers" out of hundreds of millions of pounds. The rationale for this conclusion is that some of the sales offers can be "baffling" and may offer "illusory savings."

As far Which? is concerned - and the Guardian newspaper for that matter, where it was reported - this is a very black and white story. It is, after all, very easy to hate the big supermarkets and the common narrative that they are hellbent on ripping us all off is one that never seems to grow old.

But this piece asks a subtler question, if your world admits of the possibility of shades of grey, which is this: Where - if anywhere - is the line between effective marketing and dodgy marketing? And is anybody actually being duped if they do, after all, know the price they are paying?

Decades of psychological and marketing studies have shown us a few consistent truths about marketing. For instance, more people will buy a product priced at £4.99 than they will at £5.00. Pricing at £4.99 has never been considered controversial - so presumably we accept the principle that it's all right for marketers to price in a way that customers will be more psychologically amenable to. The fact that more people will buy at £4.99 than they will at £4.50 is a remarkable additional fact - but if companies think they can get people to buy at the higher price, then that still remains uncontroversial. It's a competitive market, after all.

Supermarket with discount signs
We love a bargain - if they're real, of course

We also know that people are far more likely to buy a product that has been discounted. This is where we do start to ask a few more searching questions. The Which? report drew attention to common practice where retailers offer a product at a (arguably artifical) higher price for a short period, and then promote it as discounted for a much longer period. According to Kantar Worldpanel, around 40% of groceries in Britain are sold on promotion. That is testament to how powerful a device it really is.

There is obviously a line here. If you claimed an item was discounted when it had never actually been sold for a higher price, that is clearly wrong and is against the law. But if an item is sold on a promotion and it still has a comfortable profit margin for the company, does that in itself mean that customers are "not getting a fair deal" and are being "duped out of millions of pounds" as Which? suggests? After all, you see the product and you evaluate whether you're prepared to pay the asking price. Are psychological tricks to make you more likely to buy tantamount to deception, given that the price of the product is perfectly clear? If so, where is the line drawn from that very simple, uncontroversial pricing policy of £4.99 rather than £5.00 to the point where it becomes somehow unethical?

Where - if anywhere - is the line between effective marketing and dodgy marketing?

What about other marketing tricks? I've written before about how supermarkets sometimes pipe smells into their retail areas, such as fresh-baked bread, because people buy more food when they do this. Is that unethical manipulation, or just providing a more amenable buying environment for their customers? Since we sometimes get advised to bake bread in our homes when we're trying to sell them, does that make that unethical as well, or is it only a problem when the supermarkets do it?

Personally, my view is that clear pricing for products that are described accurately is what we expect. If you end up paying more than you think something is worth because it was discounted, or because it was priced in a certain way, or because the air was thick with the aroma of freshly ground coffee - that is a decision that you took. We do still have free will, after all. This is different to a company like Ryanair quietly adding extra charges onto the bill hoping you won't notice.

What I think on the matter is, however, irrelevant. Society makes the rules, and if enough consumers - influenced by the headline writers - demand more restrictions then no doubt they will be imposed. Legitimate marketing devices are not legitimate because scientific research says so - they are legitimate only if society as a whole tolerates them as such.

But the idea promoted by Which? that there is a universally recognisable 'fair price' for goods and services, and it is unethical to sell at a higher price, makes for fine corporate-bashing headlines, but is very hard to describe in a set of justifiable guidelines that makes sense. Which? is taking its case to the Competition and Markets Authority - it will be interesting to see if anything more substantial comes from that process other than the headlines they secured by the simple act of producing a report on the subject.