Urgently for your attention! We have nothing to report

15 August 2015

Ghost town with tumbleweed

I just received yet another of a long line of email press releases today breathlessly announcing the publication of yet another 'sustainability report.' In spite of the fact that the 'our report has been published' type headline didn't inspire interest, I thought I would delve into the list of 'report highlights' to see what sort of story the company was telling.

Here it is:

  1. They introduced a management system in their main subsidiary.
  2. They adopted some principles.
  3. They published a report.
  4. They achieved an award.
  5. They changed some aims and produced a policy.
  6. They carried out a survey with their employees.
  7. They developed some compulsory training.
  8. They created a body as part of their internal governance.
  9. They adopted a policy that set a target.
  10. They have an internal blog (pre-existing).
  11. They produced a video which showcases the company's sustainability performance (I watched the video - it doesn't showcase performance).

I haven't missed anything out, by the way. That is the full list.

I'm sure it's a good thing that the company has done all of those things, but why they think anyone would care enough that they should press-release them is absolutely beyond me. None of the above tells me what the company is trying to achieve with all its policies and processes, nor whether it is on track to achieve any real impact as a result.

Companies that don't identify their sustainability objectives don't achieve much

Having a policy, or carrying out training, or adopting a commitment, is a means to an end and that end is improved performance. I'm aware of companies that have adopted fine policies, spent large amounts of money on training and completely failed to achieve their stated aim - and then managed to get that programme to win an award! It's not good enough, and more people should be saying so.

In this company's case, I've already taken way more interest than I normally would, simply because I thought I might write about it. So, in for a penny, in for a pound, off we go to the actual report itself to see whether more interesting impact information might be lurking in the detail. In this case, you have to go some way into the detail. You first get any kind of performance data relating to sustainability performance well past page number 100. To even get there, you have to wade through enough general commentary, organisational structures and so on, as to boggle the mind.

When you do get there? Some random stats that show marginal incremental improvments on most, but not all, fronts, with no targets to provide context as to whether this represents good improvement or not. This is not a surprise. Companies that don't identify their sustainability objectives in terms of a few, most important, measurable key indicators are not clear about their own priorities and so don't achieve much.

The report is, by the way, a GRI-based report and assured as such by a third party verifier. The GRI is not to blame for the lack of focus on actual impact, but people should at least note that merely following the framework is not the same as creating a sustainable business.

I've not "named and shamed" the company concerned, because my impression is that this is a common failing, not something unique to this individual company. But honestly, if this is the accepted state of the art when it comes to sustainability reporting, it's a phenomenon that deserves to die. We should demand better.

Answer me four questions.

What will it look like for your company to be sustainable?
What do you need to do to get there?
How much progress have you made?
What are the big problems you still have to solve?

Stick everything else in the appendix. And for goodness' sake, edit out the waffle. Nearly 200 pages? Seriously?