Why CSR membership organisations like Business in the Community matter

20 June 2016

BITC Awards evening

Today it has been announced that Amanda McKenzie, the former CMO for insurance giant Aviva, is to be the new chief executive for my old firm, Business in the Community.

Organisations like BITC and, in the US, Business for Social Responsibility, have been part of the firmament for so long, it’s easy to take them for granted.

You might assume their role from this point forwards is to plod along, create a few programmes here and there, shepherd along some incremental change in the right direction whilst being largely ignored by the disruptive innovators creating new business models for sustainability.

Here are some reasons why they matter, and what they need to achieve to make their mark in the coming decade.

1. Building the community of top business leaders

BITC has been the most effective CSR membership organisation in the world for engaging the top chief executives of the major corporations. This is important because, in order for business to play its part in achieving sustainability, it has to become a natural part of leadership that you pay attention to this dimension of your business.

Any CSR organisation should be able to articulate its strategy in terms of the difference it wants to make in the world

The role of business as a pragmatic agent that takes action based on clear-sighted analysis of the facts has never been more important, particularly when you consider the growing polarisation in our societies right now. We are going to see a number of instances where business leadership is going to make the difference in the coming decade.

Has BITC always leveraged this influence? No, although it has achieved great mobilisation of business focus on key community issues over the years.

The opportunity and the challenge for the coming decade will be to ramp up engagement on core business models whilst keeping that senior leadership group on board. The time has come to show how that high level of engagement can drive the next level of change in business action.

2. Learning from the best practice of its membership and sharing the lessons

CSR organisations get hugely privileged access to insights and learning from a richly diverse membership of leading companies. Part of their role has been, and should be, to absorb that information and turn it into actionable learning that others can use.

In the past, BITC hasn’t always done this as well as it might have, with a deficit of knowledge and expertise in favour of youth and enthusiasm. There have been good signs in recent years that this has been changing a little, with more insights from leaders at BITC being posted online, and with BITC’s own intellectual capital being a bigger part of events.

The opportunity for the coming decade will be to keep its traditional focus on the practical rather than the academic, but to transform its access to the experience of its broad membership into insight that goes beyond the surface level and adds real value to those wanting to understand what are the best levers to pull to create lasting change.

3. Engaging the wider community of change-minded executives

One of the potential pitfalls of being so good at engaging the top-level decision-makers is that you can end up overlooking or discounting the role that thousands of other people will play in making change happen.

In the social media age, membership organisations should be networks that reach out to sustainability-minded executives at every level to inspire them to want to take their values to work with them. If you want to change the day-to-day culture of business, you have to address all levels, not just the very top.

You can see key membership organisations experimenting with social media, but I don’t think anyone has yet solved the challenge of reaching that wider audience. The opportunity is there for the taking, with a smart and concerted effort to make the dull corporate case studies more personal and human-focused.

The tools of engagement and influence have been transformed in the last decade. It’s time to see them put to good use. Aviva has been ahead of the curve on this one (as noted in my most recent podcast) so that may be great news for BITC in this regard.

4. Establishing priorities for business action

Twenty years ago, BITC grew to become the most successful organisation of its type because of the “let a thousand flowers bloom” approach it took under then CEO Julia Cleverdon. It incubated countless different initiatives, each focused on one issue and campaigned to attract business support wherever it could be found.

There will still be a place for lots of smaller initiatives that help address a social concern where businesses may make a difference. But the result of this approach can be that the biggest, most critical and most challenging questions become under-resourced and de-emphasised.

Any CSR membership organisation should be able to articulate its strategy in the form of the difference it wants to make in the world. That shouldn’t simply be “more good stuff in more places”. There has to be some sense of the bigger picture.

Some businesses are taking the UN Global Goals for Sustainable Development as society’s signal of where our common tasks lie. It’s not a perfect point of engagement for all businesses, but it has a lot more going for it than many of the alternatives.

5. Nurturing a political consensus for CSR

There should also be tactical questions. I’ve always felt that one of a good membership group’s tasks should be to nurture political consensus on CSR across the spectrum. When you get a government that is particularly supportive, it’s tempting to focus on all the good things that can flow from that, and lose sight of the danger that CSR becomes seen as a point of political difference.

The US has further ground to make up on this than most, since support for action on climate change has become so polarised on political grounds. But it should always be part of the working practices of any good CSR membership organisation to give leading political figures a direct experience with, and understanding of, how progressive businesses benefit society. Even political figures who wield fiery rhetoric against businesses in order to build their political base will be potentially seeking pragmatic solutions once they enter the business of actually creating change in government.

6. Celebrating excellence (and knowing what it looks like)

I was never prouder of Business in the Community when I worked there than the couple of occasions where, at its annual Awards for Excellence, it took the incredibly awkward and difficult decision to not give an award in a category where it was felt that none of the entrants had achieved a high enough standard.

The individual companies who were publicly slighted may have been furious in the short term, but it sent out the signal that it was serious about recognising best practice and not rewarding mediocrity. It helped the credibility of the whole exercise, and raised the value of achieving one of those awards amongst those who entered them.

Is that determination easy to maintain, through every case study, every award, every public statement? No, understandably not. But membership organisations should always remember they are there to challenge their members to be better, not to act as PR agents for anyone that is willing to stump up the membership.

This comes again from developing in-house knowledge and wisdom about what excellence looks like, as well as bringing in independent third-parties with similar experience for things like award judging.

There is a balance, of course. You want to encourage the slower-movers, and give them recognition for the steps they’re taking. But you still need to keep a clear vision of what excellence actually looks like.

7. Help the movement spread across the world

This is one specifically for those membership organisations that have achieved a certain size, success and maturity. Mostly that has historically meant BITC, BSR and CSR Europe.

When I was at BITC I was one of a handful of people there who ever used a passport as a tool of doing business. In so doing, I saw dozens of similar membership organisations in countries across the world, always being run on considerably scarcer resources than BITC by committed individuals who were trying to make things happen in their own country often hampered by a more hostile political or economic climate.

Wherever I went, BITC had a fantastic reputation, mostly because of one man – a gentleman by the name of David Halley. David travelled the world for BITC and did one thing only. He helped people. Anything BITC had learned how to do, he would share. He would offer placements with BITC to people that would then go on to set up organisations in their own country. He would give things away for free because it was about helping people to get things done on a shoe-string.

For all of that, it remains the case that very few of those other CSR membership organisations have ever achieved the conditions that made BITC so strong, particularly the senior level engagement with their own members. There is a huge role for the most successful groups to help, nurture and support all the others that are striving to make change happen.

Because sustainability is not a national issue. Climate change knows no national borders. And business is, by its very nature, global.

The opportunity for BITC in the future must include recapturing that generosity of spirit that saw it as a widely acknowledged force for positive change across the world, and add to that greater analysis and insight into the international dimensions of CSR in a global marketplace.

There is so much more to be done

Outgoing CEO of Business in the Community Stephen Howard did a great job, as a former CEO of FTSE250 companies, of cementing the organisation’s role as a network owned by, and supporting, the top levels of business leadership. He helped it to change and adapt during difficult economic times for the world, and to keep the commitment and engagement of business in the agenda high throughout.

There is a lot more to be done for those with the appetite for the challenge. I look forward to seeing how these vital catalysts for change continue to seize the opportunity for action and help business play its part in achieving a sustainable future.