Should your boss be telling you what to eat?

27 May 2015

Companies have become interested in your lifestyle

It is one of the most common clichés in the corporate world - when companies describe their workforce as "their greatest asset." A few years ago, socially responsible companies began to ask an important question: if that is really the case, why do we take less care of our people than we do our purely financial assets? As a result, a strong trend has emerged for companies to take an interest in wellness programmes.

At one level, the case is unarguable. On average, people who are overweight or obese suffer many more health problems. Likewise for people who do almost no exercise. Of course, often they are the same people. If you genuinely care about your employees, shouldn't you seek to encourage them to take the actions that are proven to improve their wellbeing? And if you're looking after your own bottom line, the fact that many of those health problems result in time off work is also a factor. Your people may have an overall improved quality of life if they are fit - but they will be more productive at work as well.

It is such an obvious win-win that it should be the least controversial area in the world. But the right to make your own mistakes even to your own detriment and that of your family, is something that people feel very strongly about.

If you genuinely care about your employees, shouldn't you encourage them to take action to improve their wellbeing?

Companies that have jumped too zealously into the encouragement of healthier habits have found a resentment and a backlash from the people they are trying to help. The days when benevolent industrialists provided homes and social services for their workers to ensure they lived fine, upstanding lives are more than a century gone. Now, when asked to vote on a poll at the Guardian website "are you comfortable with your workplace dictating your diet?" more than three quarters of respondants provide a resounding 'no' vote.

Of course, it's a loaded question. None of the companies concerned would say they were 'dictating people's diet'. More usually they are offering health screening, giving information, making healthy choices available and, sometimes, offering incentives or disincentives. What they are trying to do is to get the right balance - to materially influence their workforce to be healthier and to enjoy the benefits of good health, whilst at the same time avoiding setting off the alarm bells where people resent interference in their personal lives.

So what sort of thing do they do? Approximately half of US employers offer wellness promotion schemes, and around as many in the UK.

Marks & Spencer checkout
Marks & Spencer have active wellbeing programme

Before they launched their health information site "PlanA Health", Marks & Spencer made sure that they consulted with the workforce over the issues they specifically felt affected them, and which they might welcome additional information. It was an exercise that might reasonably be expected to come out with the answers you would expect - and the company would want to pursue - but it immediately positioned the exercise as one of being directed by what employees wanted to know, rather than dictating what they should have to do.

The health information site provided information, support and resources across the resulting issues - from healthy eating, stress and work-life balance to other matters that might be affecting mental wellbeing. The company worked closely with charities to give them access to online assessment tools, enabling them to pursue the vision of reaching every employee of member of the supply chain.

Of course, simply providing information doesn't get the job done. So the company has had an active programme of challenges, such as the weight loss challenge, which attracted over a thousand participants. The company was recognised for its work, winning Business in the Community's Workwell award in 2013.

But what if the results simply don't follow? Only a very small percentage of companies undertaking wellness programmes report substantial improvement in the weight profile of their employees. After all, losing weight can be a difficult task for individuals even when they're 100% voluntarily committed to doing so. How pushy can a company get in the name of social responsibility and benefiting the bottom line?

Some companies in the US have banned smokers from working for them, even if they only smoke on their own time and away from the office. Others have tried to do the same regarding eating junk food. Civil liberties organisations have objected to such practices, saying that they are a form of discrimination. Supporters have replied that it can't be discriminatory if it's focused on a pattern of behaviour that somebody could stop. Nobody has to smoke. Nobody has to eat burgers. It is purely a choice.

Others have offered health insurance benefits, offering extra discounts to people who achieve certain milestones, such as lowering their weight. Failure to achieve the goals means higher premiums. In this case nobody is micromanaging anybody's food choices. It's just that there are significant incentives to reach a goal.

The one thing that most companies include in some form is, at least, some programme of screening to provide information to employees about any conditions they might have, and what they might be able to do about it. Quite a few companies also offer financial incentives to undertake this screening which, according to a study by Rand, can make a big difference to numbers taking part.

But overall, benefits from wellness programmes are still on the light side. If companies can shift the needle even just a little in improving the health of their people - and thereby reducing the amount of time off they take - it can be worth doing. But although the Rand research found that participation with a wellness programme over five years is associated with lower health care costs, the average annual difference was an estimated $157, which they said over that timeframe was not statistically significant.

In any case, the issue continues to rise in prominence. In the UK, Business in the Community now has an active WorkWell programme which has many of the top companies signed up, and is launching a public ranking exercise to run alongside its long-established CR Index. It encourages employers not only to see the issue in terms of the health of their employees and the support that can be provided for this, but also taking their responsibility to create a happy and engaging work environment and to promote health relationships and social connections between employees.

Given the sensitivities, it is a delicate area, but one which is clearly going to receive more focus, not less, over the coming decade.